Match Review: Andre Marriner – Everton Vs Liverpool (2 – 2) [28/10/2012]

Match Review: Andre Marriner – Everton Vs Liverpool (2 – 2) [28/10/2012]

If you are new to this site and this is your first visit then please: Read this to fully understand our reviews.

Today’s referee is Andre Marriner

MATCH REVIEW DETAILS – Andre Marriner (2012-10-28)
Period 1
Min Type From On C/NC Reviewer Comment Weight
0 OFFSIDE EVE NC 2
0 CORNER LIV C José Enrique Sánchez Díaz concedes a corner kick. 1
2 CORNER EVE C Phil Jagielka concedes a corner kick. 1
3 CORNER EVE C Steven Naismith concedes a corner kick. 1
3 GOAL KICK LIV C Nuri Sahin concedes a goal kick. 1
6 THROW IN EVE C Marouane Fellaini concedes a throw in. 1
6 FOUL EVE C Steven Naismith Commits a Regular foul. 1
7 FREE KICK LIV C José Enrique Sánchez Díaz takes a direct free kick. 1
7 THROW IN EVE C Tim Howard concedes a throw in. 1
8 THROW IN LIV C Bradley Jones concedes a throw in. 1
8 CORNER LIV C Daniel Agger concedes a corner kick. 1
9 CORNER LIV C Bradley Jones concedes a corner kick. 1
10 GOAL KICK EVE C Nikica Jelavic concedes a goal kick. 1
10 THROW IN EVE C Kevin Mirallas concedes a throw in. 1
11 THROW IN EVE C Kevin Mirallas concedes a throw in. 1
11 OFFSIDE LIV C Nuri Sahin is played offside by Leighton Baines from a ball by Raheem Sterling 1
12 THROW IN LIV C Steven Gerrard concedes a throw in. 1
12 THROW IN LIV C Steven Gerrard concedes a throw in. 1
13 OWN GOAL EVE C Leighton Baines scores an own goal. 1
15 THROW IN LIV C Daniel Agger concedes a throw in. 1
15 THROW IN LIV C Steven Gerrard concedes a throw in. 1
16 THROW IN LIV C José Enrique Sánchez Díaz concedes a throw in. 1
17 FOUL LIV C Jesús Fernández Saez Commits a Regular foul. 1
17 FREE KICK EVE C Seamus Coleman takes a direct free kick. 1
17 FOUL EVE C Marouane Fellaini Commits a Regular foul. 1
18 FREE KICK LIV C Daniel Agger takes a direct free kick. 1
18 THROW IN LIV C Daniel Agger concedes a throw in. 1
18 FOUL LIV EVE NC Blocked him off the ball, not given 3
18 FREE KICK EVE NC For the foul 3
19 FOUL EVE C Leon Osman Commits a Regular foul. 1
19 YELLOW EVE C Leon Osman recieves a YellowCard for the following reason: Foul. 1
19 GOAL LIV C Luis Suárez scores a goal for Liverpool. 1
20 CORNER LIV C José Enrique Sánchez Díaz concedes a corner kick. 1
21 GOAL EVE C Leon Osman scores a goal for Everton. 1
22 THROW IN LIV C Raheem Sterling concedes a throw in. 1
22 FOUL LIV C Raheem Sterling Commits a Regular foul. 1
22 FREE KICK EVE C Leighton Baines takes a direct free kick. 1
23 THROW IN LIV C Joe Allen concedes a throw in. 1
23 THROW IN LIV C Joe Allen concedes a throw in. 1
24 THROW IN LIV C Andre Wisdom concedes a throw in. 1
24 CORNER LIV C Martin Skrtel concedes a corner kick. 1
25 FOUL EVE NC Sylvain Distin Commits a Regular foul according to the ref but the Liverpool keeper jumped in the back of the striker so no foul from Distin who didn’t move in to the keeper but it was the other way round. 3
25 FREE KICK LIV NC Bradley Jones takes a direct free kick that was wrongly awarded 3
26 THROW IN EVE C Leighton Baines concedes a throw in. 1
26 GOAL KICK LIV C Luis Suárez concedes a goal kick. 1
27 GOAL KICK EVE C Marouane Fellaini concedes a goal kick. 1
27 FOUL LIV C Nuri Sahin Commits a Regular foul. 1
28 FREE KICK EVE C Sylvain Distin takes a direct free kick. 1
28 FOUL LIV C Raheem Sterling Commits a Regular foul. 1
28 YELLOW LIV C Raheem Sterling recieves a YellowCard for the following reason: Foul. 1
28 FREE KICK EVE C Leighton Baines takes a direct free kick. 1
30 FOUL EVE C Kevin Mirallas Commits a Regular foul. 1
30 FREE KICK LIV C Andre Wisdom takes a direct free kick. 1
30 FOUL LIV C Raheem Sterling Commits a Regular foul. 1
30 YELLOW EVE NC Howard comes rushing out to the ref to ask for a second yellow card against Sterling. Ref should have drawn the line clearly there 3
31 FREE KICK EVE C Tim Howard takes a direct free kick. 1
31 OFFSIDE EVE C Nikica Jelavic is played offside by Martin Skrtel from a ball by Steven Naismith 1
33 THROW IN LIV C José Enrique Sánchez Díaz concedes a throw in. 1
34 THROW IN EVE NC The ball touched Mirallas before going out so should have been a throw in to Liverpool. 1
34 THROW IN LIV NC The ball touched Mirallas before going out so should have been a throw in to Liverpool. 1
34 GOAL EVE NC Steven Naismith scores a goal for Everton as a direct result from the wrong awarded throw in. Without this wrong throw in the goal never would have been. 5
36 THROW IN LIV C José Enrique Sánchez Díaz concedes a throw in. 1
36 THROW IN EVE C Leighton Baines concedes a throw in. 1
37 CORNER LIV C Bradley Jones concedes a corner kick. 1
38 GOAL KICK EVE C Leon Osman concedes a goal kick. 1
39 GOAL KICK LIV C Raheem Sterling concedes a goal kick. 1
40 THROW IN LIV C Steven Gerrard concedes a throw in. 1
40 FOUL LIV C Luis Suárez Commits a Regular foul. 1
41 OFFSIDE EVE C Sylvain Distin is played offside by Martin Skrtel from a ball by Leighton Baines 1
41 FREE KICK EVE C 1
42 THROW IN EVE C Leighton Baines concedes a throw in. 1
42 FOUL EVE C Kevin Mirallas Commits a Regular foul. 1
42 FREE KICK LIV C Joe Allen takes a direct free kick. 1
43 CORNER LIV C Martin Skrtel concedes a corner kick. 1
43 CORNER LIV C Martin Skrtel concedes a corner kick. 1
44 GOAL KICK EVE C Seamus Coleman concedes a goal kick. 1
45 FOUL EVE C Kevin Mirallas Commits a Regular foul. 1
45 FREE KICK LIV C Andre Wisdom takes a direct free kick. 1
45 FOUL LIV C Luis Suárez Commits a Regular foul. 1
45 YELLOW LIV NC Possible dangerous swing of the leg, could have caused an injury, should have been a yellow card 3
45 FREE KICK EVE C Tim Howard takes a direct free kick. 1
46 FOUL EVE C Philip Neville Commits a Dive foul. 1
46 YELLOW EVE C Philip Neville recieves a YellowCard for the following reason: Dive. 1
46 FREE KICK LIV C Bradley Jones takes a direct free kick. 1
47 GOAL KICK LIV C Steven Gerrard concedes a goal kick. 1
47 THROW IN LIV C Daniel Agger concedes a throw in. 1
Period 2
Min Type From On C/NC Reviewer Comment Weight
46 GOAL KICK EVE C Philip Neville concedes a goal kick. 1
47 FOUL LIV C Steven Gerrard Commits a Regular foul. 1
47 FREE KICK EVE C Phil Jagielka takes a direct free kick. 1
48 THROW IN LIV C Steven Gerrard concedes a throw in. 1
49 GOAL KICK LIV C Raheem Sterling concedes a goal kick. 1
49 FOUL LIV C Jonjo Shelvey Commits a Regular foul. 1
49 FREE KICK EVE C Phil Jagielka takes a direct free kick. 1
50 GOAL KICK EVE C Seamus Coleman concedes a goal kick. 1
50 THROW IN EVE C Marouane Fellaini concedes a throw in. 1
51 THROW IN LIV C Jonjo Shelvey concedes a throw in. 1
52 FOUL LIV C Daniel Agger Commits a Regular foul. 1
52 FREE KICK EVE C Philip Neville takes a direct free kick. 1
53 THROW IN LIV C Martin Skrtel concedes a throw in. 1
54 THROW IN LIV C Daniel Agger concedes a throw in. 1
56 FOUL EVE C Phil Jagielka Commits a Regular foul. 1
56 YELLOW EVE C Phil Jagielka recieves a YellowCard for the following reason: Foul. 1
57 FREE KICK LIV C Steven Gerrard takes a direct free kick. 1
58 GOAL KICK LIV C Daniel Agger concedes a goal kick. 1
58 GOAL KICK EVE C Marouane Fellaini concedes a goal kick. 1
59 THROW IN LIV C Bradley Jones concedes a throw in. 1
59 GOAL KICK EVE C Seamus Coleman concedes a goal kick. 1
60 THROW IN LIV C Andre Wisdom concedes a throw in. 1
61 GOAL KICK EVE C Leon Osman concedes a goal kick. 1
61 THROW IN EVE C Marouane Fellaini concedes a throw in. 1
61 THROW IN LIV C Luis Suárez concedes a throw in. 1
62 THROW IN LIV C Martin Skrtel concedes a throw in. 1
62 GOAL KICK EVE C Leon Osman concedes a goal kick. 1
63 FOUL LIV C Sebastián Coates Commits a Regular foul. 1
64 GOAL KICK EVE C Nikica Jelavic concedes a goal kick. 1
64 THROW IN LIV C Joe Allen concedes a throw in. 1
65 FOUL LIV C Joe Allen Commits a Regular foul. 1
66 FREE KICK EVE C 1
66 GOAL KICK EVE C Nikica Jelavic concedes a goal kick. 1
66 THROW IN EVE C Seamus Coleman concedes a throw in. 1
67 THROW IN LIV C Sebastián Coates concedes a throw in. 1
67 OFFSIDE LIV C Luis Suárez is played offside by Phil Jagielka from a ball by José Enrique Sánchez Díaz 1
67 FOUL LIV C Daniel Agger Commits a Handball foul. 1
68 YELLOW LIV C Daniel Agger recieves a YellowCard for the following reason: Hand. 1
68 THROW IN EVE C Magaye Gueye concedes a throw in. 1
69 THROW IN LIV C Jordan Henderson concedes a throw in. 1
70 FOUL LIV C Luis Suárez Commits a Regular foul. 1
70 2ND YELLOW LIV NC Luis Suárez recieves a YellowCard for the following reason: Foul. Should have been his second yellow card 4
70 YELLOW LIV NC Luis Suárez recieves a YellowCard for the following reason: Foul. Should have been his second yellow card 3
71 FREE KICK EVE C Tim Howard takes a direct free kick. 1
72 THROW IN LIV C Bradley Jones concedes a throw in. 1
72 THROW IN EVE C Seamus Coleman concedes a throw in. 1
73 CORNER EVE C Tim Howard concedes a corner kick. 1
74 GOAL KICK LIV C José Enrique Sánchez Díaz concedes a goal kick. 1
74 FOUL EVE C Marouane Fellaini Commits a Regular foul. 1
74 FREE KICK LIV C Joe Allen takes a direct free kick. 1
75 FOUL LIV C Jonjo Shelvey Commits a Regular foul. 1
75 FREE KICK EVE C Tim Howard takes a direct free kick. 1
76 GOAL KICK LIV C Jonjo Shelvey concedes a goal kick. 1
76 YELLOW LIV NC He kicked Distin in his private parts from behind so he knew what he was doing. Should have been booked 3
76 FOUL EVE C Steven Naismith Commits a Regular foul. 1
77 FREE KICK LIV C Daniel Agger takes a direct free kick. 1
77 FOUL EVE C Marouane Fellaini Commits a Regular foul. 1
77 FREE KICK LIV C Joe Allen takes a direct free kick. 1
78 THROW IN LIV C Jordan Henderson concedes a throw in. 1
78 FOUL LIV C Joe Allen Commits a Regular foul. Ref punished the first foul 1
78 FREE KICK EVE C Sylvain Distin takes a direct free kick. 1
79 FOUL LIV C Sebastián Coates Commits a Regular foul. 1
80 FREE KICK EVE C Philip Neville takes a direct free kick. 1
80 CORNER LIV C Martin Skrtel concedes a corner kick. 1
81 GOAL KICK EVE C Sylvain Distin concedes a goal kick. 1
81 THROW IN LIV C José Enrique Sánchez Díaz concedes a throw in. 1
82 CORNER EVE C Philip Neville concedes a corner kick. 1
83 CORNER EVE C Leighton Baines concedes a corner kick. 1
84 FOUL EVE C Steven Naismith Commits a Regular foul. 1
84 FREE KICK LIV C Joe Allen takes a direct free kick. 1
84 GOAL KICK EVE C Steven Naismith concedes a goal kick. 1
85 FOUL LIV C Raheem Sterling Commits a Regular foul. 1
85 FREE KICK EVE C Phil Jagielka takes a direct free kick. 1
85 FOUL EVE C Seamus Coleman Commits a Regular foul. 1
85 YELLOW EVE C Seamus Coleman recieves a YellowCard for the following reason: Foul. 1
86 FREE KICK LIV C Daniel Agger takes a direct free kick. 1
86 FOUL EVE LIV NC trip not given 3
86 FREE KICK LIV NC Should have been a free kick to Liverpool. 3
86 THROW IN LIV NC Should have been a free kick to Liverpool. 1
86 THROW IN LIV C Jonjo Shelvey concedes a throw in. 1
87 GOAL KICK LIV C Martin Skrtel concedes a goal kick. 1
87 FOUL LIV C Raheem Sterling Commits a Regular foul. 1
88 FREE KICK EVE C Phil Jagielka takes a direct free kick. 1
88 FOUL EVE C Sylvain Distin Commits a Regular foul. 1
88 FREE KICK LIV C 1
89 GOAL KICK LIV C Steven Gerrard concedes a goal kick. 1
89 GOAL KICK LIV C Steven Gerrard concedes a goal kick. 1
89 OFFSIDE EVE C Nikica Jelavic is played offside by Sebastián Coates from a ball by Seamus Coleman 1
91 FOUL EVE C Magaye Gueye Commits a Regular foul. 1
92 FREE KICK LIV C Daniel Agger takes a direct free kick. 1
92 FOUL EVE C Leon Osman Commits a Regular foul. 1
93 FREE KICK LIV C Steven Gerrard takes a direct free kick. 1
93 OFFSIDE LIV NC Luis Suárez is NOT played offside from a headed ball by Sebastián Coates. It was a valid goal. 2
93 GOAL LIV NC Luis Suárez is NOT played offside from a headed ball by Sebastián Coates. It was a valid goal. 5
93 THROW IN LIV C Joe Allen concedes a throw in. 1

Let us have a look at his competence numbers in this game

COMPETENCY SUMMARY – Andre Marriner (2012-10-28)
Period 1 Called Total Correct %
CORNER 10 10 100.00
FOUL 14 16 87.50
FREE KICK 13 15 86.67
GOAL 2 3 66.67
GOAL KICK 8 8 100.00
OFFSIDE 3 4 75.00
OWN GOAL 1 1 100.00
THROW IN 22 24 91.67
YELLOW 3 5 60.00
TOTAL 76 86 88.37
WEIGHTED 76 103 73.79
Period 2 Called Total Correct %
2ND YELLOW 0 1 0.00
CORNER 4 4 100.00
FOUL 21 22 95.45
FREE KICK 19 20 95.00
GOAL 0 1 0.00
GOAL KICK 17 17 100.00
OFFSIDE 2 3 66.67
THROW IN 21 22 95.45
YELLOW 3 5 60.00
TOTAL 87 95 91.58
WEIGHTED 87 111 78.38
Totals Called Total Correct %
2ND YELLOW 0 1 0.00
CORNER 14 14 100.00
FOUL 35 38 92.11
FREE KICK 32 35 91.43
GOAL 2 4 50.00
GOAL KICK 25 25 100.00
OFFSIDE 5 7 71.43
OWN GOAL 1 1 100.00
THROW IN 43 46 93.48
YELLOW 6 10 60.00
TOTAL 163 181 90.06
WEIGHTED 163 214 76.17

Let us see if it evens out in this game and have a look at the bias numbers

BIAS SUMMARY – Andre Marriner (2012-10-28)
Period 1 Everton % Liverpool % Total
Correct For 44 57.89 32 42.11 76
Correct For Weighted 44 57.89 32 42.11 76
Incorrect Against 5 50.00 5 50.00 10
Incorrect Against Weighted 15 55.56 12 44.44 27
Fouls Commited 8 50.00 8 50.00 16
Fouls Penalised 7 87.50 7 87.50 14
Period 2 Everton % Liverpool % Total
Correct For 48 55.17 39 44.83 87
Correct For Weighted 48 55.17 39 44.83 87
Incorrect Against 2 25.00 6 75.00 8
Incorrect Against Weighted 7 29.17 17 70.83 24
Fouls Commited 10 45.45 12 54.55 22
Fouls Penalised 9 90.00 12 100.00 21
Totals Everton % Liverpool % Total
Correct For 92 56.44 71 43.56 163
Correct For Weighted 92 56.44 71 43.56 163
Incorrect Against 7 38.89 11 61.11 18
Incorrect Against Weighted 22 43.14 29 56.86 51
Fouls Commited 18 47.37 20 52.63 38
Fouls Penalised 16 88.89 19 95.00 35

Please leave a comment!

This entry was posted in Everton, Liverpool, Referee Reviews. Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Match Review: Andre Marriner – Everton Vs Liverpool (2 – 2) [28/10/2012]

  1. Florian says:

    Re Suarez 70′: Wasn’t that yellow card actually correctly awarded as a consequence of his foul? I’m having trouble connecting this event to the fact that it should have been his second.

    • Walter Broeckx says:

      Florian,
      Our reviewer was from the opinion that Suarez should have had a booking in the first half for a bad tackle on an Everton player. Min 45 it was

      • Florian says:

        Agree about the one on 45′. I guess I needed to be more clear. My understanding is that on 70′, Suarez commits a bookable offence, the ref correctly books him, but incorrectly fails to send him off. In the report, both the decisions are marked as incorrect. Maybe I’m missing something here.

        • Stuart says:

          Florian, I fully agree. at 70 mins, the yellow card is correct, 2nd and therefore a sending off is not correct.

  2. nick allen says:

    im of the opinion that this system is flawed , had the player not picked up the 70th min yellow then the referee would not have been penalised those extra 7 points , so for correctly cautioning saurez in the 70th min he is penalised … i think this undermines what you are trying to achieve. sorry but this is another poor report !

    • Walter Broeckx says:

      Missing an imperative card is something that costs a ref a lot of points when he is judged by Uefa and in other countries.
      In fact the system we use to deduct points is rather soft compared to how they do it in other countries.
      I don’t have the data with me for the moment but not sending a player off results in you only can have a maximum score of 7/10 in your game.
      An example: you have to make 100 decisions. You do 99% of the decisions
      correct but you don’t send a player off when he should have been send off. Then you will get a score from the football association of 70%. And not the 99% you might expect.
      In our system you could end up with a score of 93%.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *