Match Review: Mike Dean – Aston Villa Vs Manchester City (0 – 1) [04/03/2013]

Match Review: Mike Dean – Aston Villa Vs Manchester City (0 – 1) [04/03/2013]

If you are new to this site and this is your first visit then please: Read this to fully understand our reviews.

Today’s referee is Mike Dean

MATCH REVIEW DETAILS – Mike Dean (2013-03-04)
Period 1
Min Type From On C/NC Reviewer Comment Weight
0 FOUL AST C Gabriel Agbonlahor Commits a Regular foul. 1
0 FREE KICK MNC C Pablo Zabaleta takes a direct free kick. 1
1 THROW IN MNC C Gaël Clichy concedes a throw in. 1
3 THROW IN MNC C Jack Rodwell concedes a throw in. 1
4 THROW IN MNC C Gaël Clichy concedes a throw in. 1
4 THROW IN MNC C Francisco Javier García Fernández concedes a throw in. 1
4 THROW IN AST C Matthew Lowton concedes a throw in. 1
5 CORNER MNC C Gnégnéri Yaya Touré concedes a corner kick. 1
6 GOAL KICK AST C Christian Benteke concedes a goal kick. 1
7 THROW IN AST C Fabian Delph concedes a throw in. 1
7 FOUL MNC C Francisco Javier García Fernández Commits a Regular foul. 1
7 FREE KICK AST C Brad Guzan takes a direct free kick. 1
10 THROW IN AST C Gabriel Agbonlahor concedes a throw in. 1
11 GOAL KICK MNC C Jack Rodwell concedes a goal kick. 1
12 THROW IN AST C Andreas Weimann concedes a throw in. 1
12 THROW IN MNC C Gaël Clichy concedes a throw in. 1
12 THROW IN AST C Matthew Lowton concedes a throw in. 1
13 FOUL MNC C Pablo Zabaleta Commits a Regular foul. 1
13 FREE KICK AST C Joe Bennett takes a direct free kick. 1
14 THROW IN MNC C Matija Nastasic concedes a throw in. 1
14 THROW IN AST C Ciaran Clark concedes a throw in. 1
15 THROW IN AST C Christian Benteke concedes a throw in. 1
17 CORNER AST NC Defender had the last touch, but goal kick given 2
17 GOAL KICK MNC NC Defender had the last touch, but goal kick given 1
17 FOUL AST MNC NC Benteke comes in with his arm in the neck of Zabalet and pushes him over, no foul given 3
17 FREE KICK MNC NC Ref was standing 5 meters away and didn’t see it? As a result Zabaleta gets hit with a shoe from a Villa player that wanted to kick the ball. Ref then let play continue for a few seconds while it was clear that Zabaleta was hurt on his head. 3
19 THROW IN AST C Fabian Delph concedes a throw in. 1
20 CORNER MNC C Pablo Zabaleta concedes a corner kick. 1
21 GOAL KICK AST C Matthew Lowton concedes a goal kick. 1
21 CORNER AST C Brad Guzan concedes a corner kick. 1
21 FOUL MNC C Francisco Javier García Fernández Commits a Regular foul. Cduld not see a foul but no real replay shown 1
23 FREE KICK AST C Brad Guzan takes a direct free kick. 1
23 FOUL MNC NC David Silva could not just dissapear in thin air, ref. Aston Villa player came from behind and ran half in to the back of Silva who gets the foul against him? 3
24 FREE KICK AST NC No foul so no free kick. 3
24 GOAL KICK AST C Andreas Weimann concedes a goal kick. 1
25 THROW IN MNC C Edin Dzeko concedes a throw in. 1
25 FOUL AST C Charles N’Zogbia Commits a Regular foul. 1
25 FREE KICK MNC C Gaël Clichy takes a direct free kick. 1
25 FOUL MNC C Edin Dzeko Commits a Regular foul. 1
26 FREE KICK AST C Brad Guzan takes a direct free kick. 1
26 OFFSIDE AST C Charles N’Zogbia is played offside by Kolo Touré from a ball by Nathan Baker 1
27 THROW IN MNC C Gaël Clichy concedes a throw in. 1
28 THROW IN AST C Nathan Baker concedes a throw in. 1
30 FOUL MNC C Carlos Tévez Commits a Regular foul. 1
30 FREE KICK AST C Brad Guzan takes a direct free kick. 1
30 FOUL AST C Christian Benteke Commits a Regular foul. 1
30 FREE KICK MNC C Kolo Touré takes a direct free kick. 1
31 FOUL AST C Ciaran Clark Commits a Regular foul. 1
31 FREE KICK MNC C James Milner takes a direct free kick. 1
32 THROW IN AST C Brad Guzan concedes a throw in. 1
32 THROW IN AST C Gabriel Agbonlahor concedes a throw in. 1
33 FOUL MNC C Carlos Tévez Commits a Regular foul. 1
33 FREE KICK AST C Ciaran Clark takes a direct free kick. 1
34 FOUL AST C Christian Benteke Commits a Regular foul. 1
34 FREE KICK MNC C Kolo Touré takes a direct free kick. 1
34 THROW IN AST C Ciaran Clark concedes a throw in. 1
36 THROW IN MNC C Gaël Clichy concedes a throw in. 1
36 THROW IN AST C Joe Bennett concedes a throw in. 1
37 THROW IN AST C Fabian Delph concedes a throw in. 1
37 OFFSIDE AST C Christian Benteke is played offside by Matija Nastasic from a ball by Brad Guzan 1
38 CORNER AST C Ashley Roy Westwood concedes a corner kick. 1
39 GOAL KICK MNC C James Milner concedes a goal kick. 1
40 THROW IN MNC C Carlos Tévez concedes a throw in. 1
41 GOAL KICK AST C Ashley Roy Westwood concedes a goal kick. 1
42 FOUL MNC NC Benteke first was holding Kolo Touré, but ref gave it the other way after a tussle between the two players holding each other. First foul should be punished 3
42 FOUL AST NC Benteke first was holding Kolo Touré, but ref gave it the other way after a tussle between the two players holding each other. First foul should be punished 3
43 FREE KICK MNC NC 3
43 FREE KICK AST NC 3
43 THROW IN AST C Ciaran Clark concedes a throw in. 1
44 THROW IN MNC C Pablo Zabaleta concedes a throw in. 1
44 GOAL KICK AST C Fabian Delph concedes a goal kick. 1
45 THROW IN MNC C Matija Nastasic concedes a throw in. 1
45 GOAL MNC C Carlos Tévez scores a goal for Manchester City. There was some debate if Dzeko made a foul or not but we think the Aston Villa defender first slipped and lost his footing without Dzeko having anything to do with it. 1
46 THROW IN AST C Ashley Roy Westwood concedes a throw in. 1
47 THROW IN MNC C Gaël Clichy concedes a throw in. 1
47 THROW IN MNC C James Milner concedes a throw in. 1
Period 2
Min Type From On C/NC Reviewer Comment Weight
46 CORNER AST C Joe Bennett concedes a corner kick. 1
48 GOAL KICK MNC C Matija Nastasic concedes a goal kick. 1
49 THROW IN AST C Andreas Weimann concedes a throw in. 1
49 FOUL MNC C Francisco Javier García Fernández Commits a Regular foul. 1
50 FREE KICK AST C Ashley Roy Westwood takes a direct free kick. 1
50 GOAL KICK AST C Ciaran Clark concedes a goal kick. 1
51 GOAL KICK MNC C Carlos Tévez concedes a goal kick. 1
51 FOUL AST NC I didn’t see a foul from Gabriel Agbonlahor, a good shoulder to shoulder. 3
51 FREE KICK MNC NC No foul so no free kick. 3
52 FOUL MNC C Gnégnéri Yaya Touré Commits a Regular foul. 1
52 FREE KICK AST C Nathan Baker takes a direct free kick. 1
53 THROW IN AST C Ashley Roy Westwood concedes a throw in. 1
53 THROW IN AST C Charles N’Zogbia concedes a throw in. 1
54 THROW IN MNC C Gaël Clichy concedes a throw in. 1
55 OFFSIDE AST C Christian Benteke is played offside by Kolo Touré from a ball by Brad Guzan 1
57 GOAL KICK MNC C Gnégnéri Yaya Touré concedes a goal kick. 1
58 FOUL MNC C Matija Nastasic Commits a Regular foul. 1
58 FREE KICK AST C Ashley Roy Westwood takes a direct free kick. 1
59 GOAL KICK AST C Ashley Roy Westwood concedes a goal kick. 1
60 FOUL MNC AST NC Nastacic pushes Weimann in the face and then runs off with the ball. Foul not given 3
60 FREE KICK AST NC for the previous not given foul 3
60 CORNER MNC C Kolo Touré concedes a corner kick. 1
61 CORNER MNC C Edin Dzeko concedes a corner kick. 1
62 FOUL AST C Fabian Delph Commits a Regular foul. 1
62 FREE KICK MNC C 1
63 FOUL AST C Nathan Baker Commits a Regular foul. 1
64 FREE KICK MNC C Carlos Tévez takes a direct free kick. 1
64 FOUL MNC C James Milner Commits a Regular foul. 1
65 FREE KICK AST C Brad Guzan takes a direct free kick. 1
65 THROW IN MNC C Matija Nastasic concedes a throw in. 1
66 GOAL KICK AST C Matthew Lowton concedes a goal kick. 1
67 CORNER MNC C Francisco Javier García Fernández concedes a corner kick. 1
68 FOUL MNC AST NC Tevez first trips Benett a bit, then Toure and still no foul given by the ref. 3
68 FREE KICK AST NC 3
68 THROW IN AST C Joe Bennett concedes a throw in. 1
69 FOUL MNC C James Milner Commits a Regular foul. 1
69 FREE KICK AST C 1
69 FOUL AST C Nathan Baker Commits a Regular foul. 1
70 FREE KICK MNC C Gnégnéri Yaya Touré takes a direct free kick. 1
70 FOUL MNC C Pablo Zabaleta Commits a Regular foul. 1
70 FREE KICK AST C Brad Guzan takes a direct free kick. 1
71 OFFSIDE MNC C Edin Dzeko is played offside by Joe Bennett from a ball by Gnégnéri Yaya Touré. Goal is correctly ruled out 1
71 FOUL AST C Christian Benteke Commits a Handball foul. 1
72 FREE KICK MNC C Kolo Touré takes a direct free kick. 1
73 GOAL KICK MNC C Edin Dzeko concedes a goal kick. 1
74 FOUL AST C Christian Benteke Commits a Regular foul. 1
74 YELLOW AST C Christian Benteke recieves a YellowCard for the following reason: Foul. Close to a red card but replay shows not a good angle so agree with the ref 1
75 FREE KICK MNC C Matija Nastasic takes a direct free kick. 1
75 THROW IN AST C Matthew Lowton concedes a throw in. 1
75 CORNER AST C Ciaran Clark concedes a corner kick. 1
76 THROW IN MNC C Gaël Clichy concedes a throw in. 1
77 THROW IN AST C Matthew Lowton concedes a throw in. 1
78 FOUL AST MNC NC High foot, not given 3
78 FREE KICK MNC NC for the previous foul 3
78 THROW IN AST C Christian Benteke concedes a throw in. 1
80 GOAL KICK AST C Andreas Weimann concedes a goal kick. 1
81 THROW IN MNC C Gnégnéri Yaya Touré concedes a throw in. 1
81 THROW IN MNC C Gnégnéri Yaya Touré concedes a throw in. 1
82 THROW IN MNC C Francisco Javier García Fernández concedes a throw in. 1
82 CORNER AST C Ciaran Clark concedes a corner kick. 1
83 GOAL KICK AST C Simon Dawkins concedes a goal kick. 1
84 GOAL KICK MNC C Samir Nasri concedes a goal kick. 1
85 THROW IN AST C Karim El Ahmadi concedes a throw in. 1
87 FOUL AST NC Benteke goes to the ball with his arms and touches it at the same time as Kolo Toure plays it with his feet, ref gives no handball but Benteke stays in control of the ball. 3
87 FREE KICK MNC NC After the Benteke handbal, Nastacic also handled the ball and that was also a deliberate handball. The ref should have given the first handball but this also was blatant. Should have been given a free kick to Manchester City 3
88 GOAL KICK AST C Christian Benteke concedes a goal kick. 1
89 THROW IN AST C Joe Bennett concedes a throw in. 1
90 THROW IN MNC C David Silva concedes a throw in. 1
90 THROW IN MNC C Edin Dzeko concedes a throw in. 1
90 THROW IN MNC C Gaël Clichy concedes a throw in. 1
91 THROW IN MNC C Kolo Touré concedes a throw in. 1
91 CORNER MNC C Gaël Clichy concedes a corner kick. 1
92 GOAL KICK AST C Matthew Lowton concedes a goal kick. 1
93 FOUL AST C Fabian Delph Commits a Handball foul. 1
93 YELLOW AST C Fabian Delph recieves a YellowCard for the following reason: Hand. 1
93 FREE KICK MNC C Pablo Zabaleta takes a direct free kick. 1
94 THROW IN MNC C Edin Dzeko concedes a throw in. 1

Let us have a look at his competence numbers in this game

COMPETENCY SUMMARY – Mike Dean (2013-03-04)
Period 1 Called Total Correct %
CORNER 4 5 80.00
FOUL 11 15 73.33
FREE KICK 11 15 73.33
GOAL 1 1 100.00
GOAL KICK 7 8 87.50
OFFSIDE 2 2 100.00
THROW IN 30 30 100.00
TOTAL 66 76 86.84
WEIGHTED 66 93 70.97
Period 2 Called Total Correct %
CORNER 7 7 100.00
FOUL 12 17 70.59
FREE KICK 12 17 70.59
GOAL KICK 12 12 100.00
OFFSIDE 2 2 100.00
THROW IN 20 20 100.00
YELLOW 2 2 100.00
TOTAL 67 77 87.01
WEIGHTED 67 97 69.07
Totals Called Total Correct %
CORNER 11 12 91.67
FOUL 23 32 71.88
FREE KICK 23 32 71.88
GOAL 1 1 100.00
GOAL KICK 19 20 95.00
OFFSIDE 4 4 100.00
THROW IN 50 50 100.00
YELLOW 2 2 100.00
TOTAL 133 153 86.93
WEIGHTED 133 190 70.00

Let us see if it evens out in this game and have a look at the bias numbers

BIAS SUMMARY – Mike Dean (2013-03-04)
Period 1 Aston Villa % Manchester City % Total
Correct For 30 45.45 36 54.55 66
Correct For Weighted 30 45.45 36 54.55 66
Incorrect Against 0 0.00 10 100.00 10
Incorrect Against Weighted 0 0.00 27 100.00 27
Fouls Commited 7 46.67 8 53.33 15
Fouls Penalised 5 71.43 6 75.00 11
Period 2 Aston Villa % Manchester City % Total
Correct For 33 49.25 34 50.75 67
Correct For Weighted 33 49.25 34 50.75 67
Incorrect Against 6 60.00 4 40.00 10
Incorrect Against Weighted 18 60.00 12 40.00 30
Fouls Commited 9 52.94 8 47.06 17
Fouls Penalised 6 66.67 6 75.00 12
Totals Aston Villa % Manchester City % Total
Correct For 63 47.37 70 52.63 133
Correct For Weighted 63 47.37 70 52.63 133
Incorrect Against 6 30.00 14 70.00 20
Incorrect Against Weighted 18 31.58 39 68.42 57
Fouls Commited 16 50.00 16 50.00 32
Fouls Penalised 11 68.75 12 75.00 23

Please leave a comment!

This entry was posted in Aston Villa, Manchester City, Referee Reviews. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *